Freedom of speech and the left

471 posts / 0 new
Last post
JKR

Half of all Israeli hostage posters in London are ripped down within 48 hours

Each week, 20,000 posters in the capital bearing faces and names of those snatched by Hamas are removed, say activists

Half of all the posters in London bearing the faces of hostages held in Gaza are being removed within 48 hours, with many of them ripped down as soon as they appear. 

Posters displaying the faces and names of the hundreds of victims snatched by Hamas and held in Gaza since October 7 have become a familiar sight over the past four weeks. 

Volunteers have taped up the distinctive red and white posters, emblazoned with the word “Kidnapped” in large letters, on buildings, telephone boxes, shop shutters, lampposts and street signs in an act of solidarity with the victims in Israel and in an effort to keep the hostages front of mind among the wider public.

In London alone, they are putting up at least 40,000 posters each week, according to campaign co-ordinator Ari, who asked to be identified only by his first name due to safety concerns. 

But in a disturbing expression of hostility toward the innocent victims, at least 50 per cent of these posters are vanishing from the capital almost as quickly as volunteers can tape them up, according to Ari. Others are defaced. This behaviour is being echoed in other UK cities, and abroad, in the US.

While the community in London is confronted with the sight of the ripped remnants, Greater Manchester Police are investigating after an officer was filmed removing posters stuck to a temporary wall outside a building site close to an area with a large Jewish population. 

Asked how long most of the posters in London tend to stay up, Ari said: “Twenty-four to 48 hours maximum, [though] some are there for longer.” 

He estimated that within this time frame, at least 50 per cent are removed. 

“People, mostly Muslim and ‘free Palestine’ [activists], come and tear them off,” said Ari, an Israeli working in IT. 

“We instructed the volunteers not to do anything, just take videos [and ask] ‘Why are you doing that?’” 
The volunteers work in groups for safety but have been met with aggression and explicit racism at times. 

Ari said: “A few times I have had some guys shouting… ‘F*** you, f*** off, free Palestine, Jews out, Yahud, go away.’” 

The number of volunteers arranging for the posters to be printed and putting them up — a few hundred people, the majority of whom are Jewish or Israeli Londoners — is dwarfed by the volume of anti-Israel activists intent on ripping them down. 

Ari said: “They have so many supporting the idea. We are quite small.” 

The volunteers in London are working closely with their counterparts in Manchester, where hostage posters are also being removed. 

Greater Manchester Police is investigating after footage posted to social media on Monday appeared to show a community support officer pulling posters off a temporary wall surrounding a building site in Prestwich, which is home to a large Jewish community. 

GMP Chief Constable Stephen Watson, said he was “very concerned” and admitted that the officer had “got it wrong”. 

Speaking to BBC Radio Manchester, he said: “My early understanding is that there were a series of complaints about the posters, an officer [was] deployed — in fact it was a PCSO — and the PCSO, under instruction, removed the posters.” 
 

He added that he did not believe the officer’s intent had been “malicious”, saying: ”I think, reading between the lines, this is where we’ve responded badly to a complaint and I think we’ve got it wrong, and we have not operated in accordance with our instructions.” 

In London, Ari and his fellow volunteers are determined to keep replacing the posters, and have launched an online crowdfunder to help cover the printing costs, which run into hundreds of pounds per week. 

“At first, we used Sellotape [on the posters] but now we’ve found a much stronger glue, which will make it harder for them to take them off,” Ari said. 

He added that the volunteers involved in the movement to support the captives in Israel will not be deterred by those who attempt to intimidate them: “The energy is there in the Jewish community in the UK.” 

Commenting on the quantities of posters being removed, the Campaign Against Antisemitism said: “Tearing down posters of missing people kidnapped by Hamas terrorists is about the lowest of the low. 

“This vile behaviour appears to be an attempt to conceal the barbaric abductions and shield the terrorist group behind them from the disgust that the public feels. 

“It is frightening to think that such animus toward Jews exists so widely on the streets of Britain.” 

The spokesperson added: “British society urgently needs to remember what our values are.”

JKR

Viral video shows people removing posters of kidnapped Israeli hostages

Demonstrators and DPS were recorded on separate videos removing signs near a campus entrance.

Days after posters of Israelis kidnapped by Hamas were posted on and around USC’s campus, demonstrators and DPS officials were filmed removing them.

ATVN reported Thursday several students from the USC Chabad House put up those posters on and around campus. The posters were placed around Jefferson Avenue, 28th Street, Troy Hall and other locations around campus.

The posters are missing signs of people captured by Hamas, a militant group and U.S.-designated terrorist organization, during their surprise attack against Israel on October 7. The signs list the name, age and pictures of the victims. They also urge the reader to “please help bring them home alive.”

In a video posted to USC Chabad’s Instagram story Thursday night, two individuals were filmed taking down and throwing away posters of the hostages held by Hamas.

The video was filmed near University Avenue at the front of the school. Posters were put up on street lamps and bus stop benches.

In the video, two individuals with a bag full of crunched-up posters are confronted about taking down the posters.

The video, which received national attention, shows the following interaction:

“Excuse me, why are you taking those off? Why are you taking those off?”

“Because it’s causing the conflict to be worse…”

“My friends are one of those 200 people and you’re taking them off.”

“And that’s sad but I don’t see how that helps the conflict. People are just killing each other more and more.”

In a separate video obtained by Annenberg Media, a Department of Public Safety officer was also seen taking down posters that were on campus. In a university statement, a representative said that the university was enforcing its policy outlined in the USC Student Handbook.

The university “[applies] that policy consistently, without regard to the content of the flyers,” according to the representative.

The posters are part of the international movement #KidnappedFromIsrael. Nitzan Mintz and Dede Bandaid, two Israeli artists from Tel Aviv, created the project and its accompanying website, which features testimonials from familiesaffected by the kidnappings and a list of 203 of Hamas’ hostages.

“We want people to pass by and look and understand that this is real… we’re talking about real people being held captive,” Bandaid said in an interview with Annenberg Media. “We’re talking about people: Babies and toddlers, men, women, grandparents… being held by militant people with guns.”

Rabbi Dov Wagner, who runs the Rohr Chabad Jewish Center at USC, called the teardown of the posters “an attempt to erase the value of human beings.”

“This isn’t a political statement; these people are being held hostage,” he said.

Junior Andrew Turquie said he was disappointed by the removals.

“I was quite upset. I felt like our community wasn’t being supported again. I felt like you were using university policies or guidelines per se to put down the Jewish community,” Turquie said.

On Instagram, USC Hillel put out a message regarding the posters getting taken down.

“The intent of the students who posted these flyers was to draw attention to the tragedy of these 200 Israeli hostages,” the message read. “We will not allow them to be erased. These are our friends and our family, and we are praying for their safe return”

Innocent lives are being lost on both sides of the war, which further calls for empathy and kindness from the student body, according to Wagner. However, “rather than hearing and empathizing with each other, it just seems that things are being erased to the loudest voice,” he said.

Wagner said that the USC community should focus on exhibiting resilience and strength. Students can come together to connect and bring positivity to each other during these times, and while community members may not reach a consensus at the moment, they can, “at the very least, not call for the erasure of the other,” he said.

“It’s important for people all over to pause a little bit before saying something,” Wagner said. “Is it achieving something? Is it bringing light to the world, or are you just trying to bring someone else down?”

JKR

Posters of Israelis kidnapped by Hamas in US opens new front of contention

Posters of Israeli hostages, held by the Hamas after the October 7 attack, on the sidewalks and subways in the US have inflated the ongoing tension as people divide over the purpose of the flyers.

The posters featuring "Kidnapped" in bright red block letters with photos of captives -- according to some it is an urgent reminder of the men, women and children held in the Gaza strip and for some, it is "wartime propaganda", as people have been tearing the posters in collage campuses and around the cities down. 

“You should be ashamed of yourselves,” a man said in a video posted on social media as he watched two young people at the University of Southern California shove wadded-up posters into the trash, according to The New York Times.

The display of posters featuring hostages has become a unique form of activism to keep the issue in the public eye. However, the act of removing these posters has evolved into a distinct form of protest, serving as both a "release of tension" and a "provocation by individuals" deeply concerned about the Israeli government's treatment of Palestinians before the October 7 attack and subsequent airstrikes.

The act of tearing down these posters has resulted in some individuals facing backlash on social media. 

Notably, a dentist in Boston and an individual in South Florida have lost their jobs due to their involvement in removing the posters.

Those who oppose the posters have labelled them as wartime propaganda, while those defending the right to display them have accused the act of tearing them down as being "antisemitic" and "lacking in basic humanity". 

These disputes have increasingly taken on a volatile tone, serving as a proxy battle for the larger and ongoing life-and-death conflict in the Middle East.

For Nitzan Mintz, one of the artists responsible for creating the posters, the virality of the campaign was a surprise. However, witnessing people forcibly remove the posters has exposed what she believes to be clear instances of antisemitism.

“By accident, this campaign did more than bring an awareness of the kidnapped people. It brought awareness of how hated we are as a community,” Mintz was quoted as saying by NYT.

A woman in the Brooklyn borough, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to the NYT, said, "She had torn down kidnapped posters after a friend in a group chat for activists encouraged her". She said the posters, according to her friend, "amounted to anti-Islamic war propaganda".

JKR

Kidnapped from Israel’ flyers reflect anguish over hostages even as they draw controversy

The two Israeli artists were visiting New York when the frantic texts and calls began: Hamas had attacked Israel, leaving a trail of grisly killings and taking hostages. 

Too far away to help, the couple decided to use their street art backgrounds – designing stark red-and-black flyers bearing the word “kidnapped” above photos and names of the abducted, from children to the elderly.  

Nitzan Mintz, 32, and the artist who goes by the name Dede Bandaid, 36, took stacks of them into Manhattan on Oct. 9 to paste them up and give them out. Few passersby, however, were interested.

Dejected, they went home, put the flyers in a public cloud storage file, posted on social media and went to bed. “When we woke up, it was already going viral,” Bandaid said.

The “Kidnapped from Israel” flyers have since become viral symbols of more than 200 Hamas hostages – plastered on walls, subways and telephone poles in cities across the U.S. and beyond, translated into 30 languages and promoted by some celebrities.

But while they have highlighted the plight of the hostages, the posters have also at times highlighted public divides over the larger Israeli-Palestinian conflict and its complicated history.

Bandaid has seen many posters torn down in his daily treks into the New York streets. It also has happened in South Florida: A dentist in Miami was fired after being filmed tearing down flyers. A New York college studentdrew outrage for a similar incident. And the flyers have been targeted in other U.S. cities as well as in Londonand Melbourne, Australia.

Since Hamas attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 6,400 have died on both sides, according to the United Nations. 

Though the rationale behind tearing down posters is often unstated, Bandaid said he wants peace for all sides. The project’s aim, he said, is simply to keep the hostages in the public eye and press for their release. 

“They can tear it down,” he said. “We will put it back up.”

Street-art campaign goes viral

The flyers, which the creators describe as a form of guerrilla public street art, were modeled on missing-persons posters familiar to U.S. residents.

The idea came out of brainstorming sessions with Mintz and others in the wake of the attacks and was created in partnership with Israeli designers including Tal Huber, who Bandaid said was in Israel in the days after the attack, listening to rockets fly overhead. The website also credits designer Shira Gershoni.

“We heard about the enormous number of people being kidnapped, and from all ages – babies, toddlers, to elderly people … just horrible,” Bandaid said. “We said: 'We have to do something. To put the message out there, to tell the story.'”

It wasn’t long before demand for the flyers crashed their public DropBox. So they created a webpage with downloadable flyers. 

The campaign took off. People with tape and staple guns, and their own printouts of posters downloaded from the site, began spreading the flyers in cities from San Francisco to New York, as well as in Europe and South America. They became features of pro-Israel demonstrations and appeared on college campuses.

Two weeks into it, Bandaid said, about 25,000 people are visiting the site each day. It now also includes video clips of Israelis being kidnapped and video testimonials by family members of hostages. 

“People also made billboards and digital TV trucks with advertisements that drive around the cities like in London and Berlin,” he said. “It's everywhere.”

Fliers drawn into public divides 

The posters’ rapid spread has at times drawn the project into public debates surrounding the conflict.

U.S. polls have shown that while older generations remain more strongly sympathetic to Israel, millennials, and many who are younger, are almost evenly split on whether they align more with Israelis or Palestinians. 

Videos of people taking the flyers down at various locations, including New York University, have fueled outrage. New York Jewish Weekrecently reported that flyers were torn down within minutes of going up at the Union Square subway, contributing to a heated exchange between a poster and a pro-Palestinian activist.

In Boston, a woman found ripping down posters of Israeli hostages at a shopping center has been fired from her job, the Boston Herald reportedthis week. 

And in Miami, dentist Ahmed Elkoussa was fired after he was filmed taking down posters. ElKoussa has since contended that he removed signs because he worried they would fuel tensions. 

“Anything inciteful is not the answer right now,” he told WPLG-TV.

After Harvard University student groups drew a fierce backlash for issuing a statement blaming the violence on Israel’s treatment of Palestinians, the flyers appeared all over campus.

Bandaid, too, has seen the flyer torn down as he walks the streets of New York each day, pasting up hundreds of the posters. 

He knows the debate is charged, but he says the campaign is about freeing innocent hostages, seemingly something people could agree upon.

“That could be their kids, their mother, their grandparents.”

‘Kidnapped’ project upends artists' lives 

Two weeks since it began, the project has come to consume Mintz and Bandaid’s daily lives, he said.

They and others talk daily with families of hostages, obtaining permissions, family photos or getting updates. Many are now reaching out to them, fearing their loved ones' plight will be forgotten. 

“It’s a situation that we never thought we were going to be in. We’re artists, and we’re talking to families whose world has just collapsed,” he said. “There’s a lot of pain.”

The flyers give a powerful window into that pain. Among them: a 34-year-old mother and her two daughters, pictured smiling by the seaside. A 9-month-old Israeli-Argentinian baby, pictured holding a colorful ball. A 40-year-old Israeli, smiling in a sun hat, who was taken from a music festival. 

In some ways, they were reminiscent of the missing-person flyers that appeared around New York after 9/11.

The couple stay glued to fast-moving developments. On Monday, Hamas released two women. Two days earlier, Hamas released an American-Israeli mother and daughter who had been visiting Israel from suburban Chicago. 

What will happen next – as hostage families worry about what a ground invasion will mean for the captives – isn’t clear. It’s day by day for families of hostages and those advocating for their release, whatever means they are using. 

“And every day is like you don't know how it's going to start,” Bandaid said. “And you don't know how it's going to end.”

JKR

VIDEO: Barrie woman in hot water for ripping down Israeli posters

'It was very disheartening to see that somebody would do such a thing,' says Barrie woman who filmed interaction

Nov 1, 2023 8:00 PM

Editor's note: The video attached to this article contains strong language that may not be suitable for some readers. The following story has also been updated to include comments from the Downtown BIA.

A brief but highly charged interaction caught on video in downtown Barrie last week has gone viral.

Barrie resident Madi Foglia, 18, was putting up posters of “missing and kidnapped Israeli children” on Wednesday, Oct. 25, in connection to the ongoing Israel-Hamas war, when she says she noticed a woman removing them, so she confronted her.

When the woman — later identified as Downtown Barrie BIA employee Sarah Jensen, who works as its communications and public realm co-ordinator — was asked why she was removing the posters, she said they did not “bring light to the other side of the situation at all.”

“I had been walking back to check where the posters I had originally put up were to see if anybody had taken them down, because I had seen videos of people doing that,” Foglia said. “I asked her what (she) was doing.

"I immediately knew to start recording because of how I had seen other interactions go. They’d gotten violent ... It was very disheartening to see that somebody would do such a thing," Foglia added. 

At the time of the interaction, Foglia said she was unaware who she was speaking to, but after her video was shared through various social media platforms, she learned the woman she confronted was Jensen.

Jensen declined an interview request. However, she has posted a statement on her Facebook page, saying her actions that day were her own and done on her own time outside of work, and do not reflect on the Downtown Barrie BIA, its board or members.

“The conflict in Israel and Palestine has been all over the news and social media lately and, like many others, I’ve felt overwhelmed by it at times," Jensen said in the post. 

"My emotions got the better of me when I was faced with dozens of posters of kidnapped Israeli citizens posted in downtown Barrie," she added. "I took some of those posters down and was subsequently confronted and filmed by the person who had put them up. I didn’t act out of hate, but I acted rashly and didn’t consider that my actions would cause hurt to Jewish people in our community."

Jensen apologized "to everyone who feels outraged or unsafe because of my actions. And I apologize for the disrespect that my actions showed towards the victims and their families. My actions were wrong and divisive, and in hindsight I see that they only worsened the situation.”

After reading Jensen’s apology, Foglia says she feels it is Jensen’s actions, and not her words, that speak the loudest.

“I feel she is only saying that because she got caught. Everybody acts so proudly until there are consequences,” Foglia said. “It was very disheartening. These are the people who are supposed to have your best interest in mind. They are supposed to be there for the community and she’s supposed to represent the downtown community.”

On Friday, Oct. 27, the Downtown Barrie BIA posted a brief statement on the blog portion of its website noting it was looking into the incident.

“The Downtown Barrie BIA, as an independent organization, does not condone violence in any manner to any human for any circumstance," it says. "While the actions of an employee of the BIA were conducted outside of formal work hours, due to the serious nature of the circumstances, an internal investigation has been undertaken. A further statement will be issued upon completion of the investigation."

On Wednesday afternoon, Downtown Barrie BIA executive director Craig Stevens said the organization is currently working through its investigation.

Coun. Craig Nixon, who represents the downtown and sits on the BIA board, also said he is waiting on those results. 

“Since this is an ongoing confidential HR (human resources) issue and is currently being investigated I am unable to comment at this time,” he said Wednesday morning. “I can say that I am awaiting the results of the investigation at which time the board will meet and decide on appropriate actions to be taken.”

Foglia says the response from the Downtown Barrie BIA is simply too little too late.

“When I attempted to reach out to them, they didn’t speak to me. They actually blocked me,” Foglia said, adding she believes they are in "damage control" mode.

“For them to shut it down, only to release a statement days later rather than an immediate condemnation … it felt like they were trying to limit the exposure to the immediate downtown community," Foglia added. 

Foglia estimates she’s put up upwards of 400 posters around the city in recent weeks, and says she doesn’t have plans to stop anytime soon.

The recent interaction left her feeling upset and angry, but also says it has also strengthened her resolve.

“The Jewish community, our voices are being ignored," Foglia said.

She says she eventually returned to the downtown library to print off more posters and headed back downtown with friends to replace the ones that had been removed. 

"Clearly there is an issue with people feeling offended. The posters didn’t mention Palestine at all. They didn’t mention Israel. They mentioned Hamas," she said. "The posters were not one-sided. I told her (to) put up her own posters … if she wanted I’d have helped. She can put up her own posters for the missing (and) murdered Palestinian children, but these were my posters. Hamas is a terrorist group.” 

JKR

My Old Friend Is Ripping Down Posters of Kidnapped Children

My daughter is scared of the dark. We got her a nightlight—it glows purple—which helps. Still, she likes my husband or me to lie in bed with her until she falls asleep. She’ll wrap her arm around my neck as she drifts off, and whisper things like “I love you, Mommy” and “What are we doing tomorrow?” She is four and a half. 

My son likes for me to read him a book before bed. Right after I give him a bottle of milk, he looks up at me with his stunning green eyes and begs, “Book! Book!” though the k is silent—a syllable he has not yet mastered—so it sounds more like “Buh! Buh!” I read The Going to Bed Book, by Sandra Boynton, to him. He is one and a half. He giggles as I place him in his crib and turn off the lights.

More than thirty Israeli children, some as young as 9 months old, are currently being held captive by Hamas terrorists inside Gaza. If they are still alive, they have now spent seventeen nights away from their beds. Some of them are alone. Some of them are with their siblings. Some of them watched their parents die in front of their eyes.

None of them are getting bedtime stories or purple nightlights. 

There are a lot of horrors that have been reported in the last seventeen days—rape that broke women’s pelvic bones, babies riddled with bullets, children whose fingers and feet were cut off, entire families that were burned to death with their hands tied behind their backs, a pregnant woman whose fetus was cut out of her stomach while she was still alive. For parents, though, there may be nothing as agonizing as the ongoing terror of children being held captive by an ISIS-style jihadist terrorist organization that revels in Jewish suffering. As one parent put it, that would be worse than death.

There have been widespread, grassroots efforts to bring attention to the kidnapped civilians, especially the children. One information campaign that has been gaining traction is called Let the World Know, which was started by Anna Tambini, an Israeli woman who lives in San Francisco. Volunteers across America, and around the world, have been hanging posters of the hostages on streetlights and posts, subway walls and coffee shops. Each poster has an individual picture and name with a simple call to action: “Take a photo of this poster and share it. Please help bring them home alive.” 

There is no Israeli flag on these posters. There is no mention of politics. They are as anodyne as the missing children that used to appear on the side of American milk cartons. 

And still. People all over the world—especially young, cool-looking people, with nose rings and neon backpacks—are ripping them down.

Across the internet, videos have emerged of people angrily tearing down these posters wherever they find them. In NYC. In L.A. In San Diego. In Santa Cruz. In Richmond. In Miami. In Philadelphia. In Ontario. In Paris. In London. They are ripping the faces of real people who are missing—babies, children, teenagers, women, elderly—to shreds.

I’m not sure non-Jews and ordinary passersby understand how painful this is. The Jewish world is tiny and connected. Nearly everyone knows someone who knows one of those faces. A friend’s friend. The in-laws of the sister of a boy who went to your school. And that’s just me.

I was scrolling Instagram this week when I came across another one of these videos. This one was of a woman and a man together ripping down the posters in Williamsburg. I almost skipped past it when I noticed something. I turned up the volume. 

After the woman finishes scraping the remainders of the poster from the street post, while muttering the word calba, the Arabic word for dog, she then turns to the camera—presumably to the person filming her vandalism—and says, “Fuck you. Fuck you. And burn in hell.”

And that’s when my heart dropped: I know her. 
 

Sarah—who I’ve since learned from the internet seems to go by the name Lucky and prefers they/them pronouns—and I went to college together at Northwestern. We weren’t close friends, but we performed in a show we wrote together along with five other women, and we were friendly enough to have hung out more than a few times. We even have a handful of pictures together on Facebook from 2011 (which I dug up in order to prove to myself that this was the same person). In more than one photo we are side by side, arms wrapped around each other, smiling. 

I remember having lunch or coffee with Sarah before I went to study abroad in Jerusalem my junior year, and we talked about our very different perspectives. She was Palestinian, and she told me that her family was unable to travel to Israel. I listened. How unfair, I thought at the time, that I’m about to board a flight to Tel Aviv, when her family members aren’t even allowed to go visit their place of birth. We left the meal—and the conversation—without raising our voices. Without saying “fuck you” or “burn in hell.” 

I haven’t talked to Sarah in twelve years. I don’t know how she went from the girl I performed with at Kresge Hall, ranting about feminism and consent—typical college-aged defiance and edge—to standing on a street corner, tearing apart pictures of kidnapped Israelis and flinging them to the ground like a dirty tissue. In her online bio it says that she has a master’s in social work from University of Chicago and that she is working to better her community through “internal, interpersonal, and systems change.” It also says that she is “dedicated to supporting queer and trans youth as they learn to love themselves, radically and unapologetically, and gain a healthier understanding of their resilience and power.” (Sarah perhaps doesn’t know that queerness can get you arrested, and far worse, in Gaza.) On a “30 Under 30” award she won a few years ago, she describes herself as a prison abolitionist, a therapist, a social worker, a sexual assault crisis counselor, a teaching artist, a resource advocate, and a performer in participatory educational theater. 

It is painfully ironic that the one thing you don’t need an advanced degree or elitist jargon for—you know, standing against the kidnapping of innocent children—is the one thing this “queer, gender-fluid femme of color,” as she labels herself, is utterly unable to grasp. It may well be that those advanced degrees are precisely what has emboldened her to commit such acts in the name of progress or power or resilience or resistance. 

I’ve watched the video over a dozen times. It is unbearable to think that I was friends with this person. 

But I was. I know this person. I knew her. She was not an antisemite. She was not a sadist. And so, with the splinter of hope I have left, I wrote a long text message to the number I have saved in my phone from so long ago. I asked why she thought, as she wrote on a now-private (or deleted) Instagram post, that these posters are “propaganda.” I told her, calmly, that these are real people and real children. And on the other side of those posters are real mothers and real fathers and real brothers and real sisters who are living in agony waiting for any sign that their loved ones are alive.

I ended with this: “The only purpose of this message is to explain my people’s very real suffering and pain, and hope that it touches or resonates with you in some way. I hope it makes you reconsider ripping down any more posters in the city.” And finally: “None of what I’ve written takes away from Palestinian suffering. I cry for everyone.” 

If she got the message, she hasn’t answered me yet. 

Before bed the other night, my daughter asked me if I knew what was going on in Israel. 

“I do,” I told her. “Do you?” 

“Yes,” she said with confidence. She continued, “But will the bad guys come here to Atlanta?” 

“Never,” I told her. 

“How come?” she pushed. Before I could answer, she came up with her own: “Because we lock our doors, right? So they could never get in?”

“That’s right,” I told her. I didn’t have the heart to tell her the truth.

When she’s older, however, I will tell her this: if anyone stole my kids from their beds, I would go to the ends of the earth to bring them home, including—at a very minimum—putting up posters on every damn block in America. 

My former friend says she is dedicating her life to bettering the world, to justice. Yet she proudly rips the faces of captured children and calls them dogs. Because they’re Jews. Tonight I will linger a little longer when I kiss my daughter and son goodnight.

Candace Mittel Kahn is the executive producer of Honestly and audio projects at The Free Press.

JKR

Poster of Israeli child hostages defaced with ‘Hitler moustaches’

Met investigating the vandalism as a hate crime as Kemi Badenoch condemns ‘hostility directed towards our Jewish communities’

epaulo13

..mr. tit for tat trying to equate the tearing down of posters to institutional government and corporate censorship. 

..political analysis not his forte.

JKR

epaulo13 wrote:

..mr. tit for tat trying to equate the tearing down of posters to institutional government and corporate censorship. 

..political analysis not his forte.

You don’t own this thread. This thread is titled "Freedom of speech and the left" not "institutional government and corporate censorship." Tearing down posters opposes freedom of speech. It sounds like you don’t mind those posters being torn down. Maybe you can’t accept the simple universal message they represent?

epaulo13

..you don't get to ignore the occupation. the very core of this dispute. a barbaric travesty....yet you do.  

..over and over again you repeat that the war in the ukraine can end. all russia has to do is leave. but you don't say the same about the occupation of the palistinian people. a sad political hypocrisy.  

JKR

..you don't get to ignore the unacceptance of the existence of Israel and the violence perpetrated against Israelis and Jews the very core of this dispute. a barbaric travesty....yet you do.  

..over and over again you repeat that the war in ukraine can end. all Ukraine has to do is sign a peace agreement with Russia but you don't say the same about the lack of peace for Israelis and Jewish people. a sad political hypocrisy.

epaulo13

..yet you ignore the vastly superior violence inflicted by israel. in both breath and scope. then try and equalize the violence being produced. 

..that is not only political dishonesty but racist in it's implication that palestinians deserve these current attacks. and that they brought the occupation on themselves.

..a totally ridiculous position viewed through a human rights lens. talk like this i would imagine would be similar to having a discussion with trump. round and round you go. where nothing changes except increased violence.

JKR

epaulo13 wrote:

..yet you ignore the vastly superior violence inflicted by israel. in both breath and scope. then try and equalize the violence being produced. 

The Israeli - Palestinian conflict is just a part of other much greater conflicts. The other conflicts are the Israeli - Iran conflict, the Arab - Iran conflict, the Arab - Israeli conflict, and the Russia vs the West conflict. Iran has no interest in peace between Israeli and Palestinians. Iran is only interested in creating conflicts against Israel even if it means using Palestinians as canon fodder. Iran supports terrorist groups like Hamas as a way to go to war with Israel. Iran also views Sunni Muslim countries like Saudi Arabia as being their enemies. That’s why Sunni Muslim countries have been befriending Israel. Israel’s goal in Gaza is to eradicate the ability of Iran to go to war with Israel through using Hamas and Hezbolah as their proxies. If Hamas / Iran cared anything about peace they would immediately return the Israeli hostages they have taken violently to Gaza.

epaulo13

..that's a lie. and an argument for you to refuse to see the massive humanitarian crisis that the occupation is. 

JKR

Why do you think Israel has taken the actions it has over the last 75 years?

Why do you think the international community has not agreed with your perspective?

epaulo13

..the issue with the palistinians is a land and water grab. there has never been a serious threat against the state of israel for many many years. 

..the other issue is one of race. which is why they call it apartheid. 

..every year for many many years the un has condemned the occupation. you are very well aware of this. yet you ask. any action is then vetoed. again you know this and yet you ask.

..why do you pose that question? you see the power players in the world stacking up sides as they bring the world to the brink of destruction. you attempt to use this leadership to make your case?  

JKR

epaulo13 wrote:

..the issue with the palistinians is a land and water grab.

The West Bank and Gaza are minuscule areas that don’t have much economic value in the greater scheme of things. Israel itself is minuscule compared to its neighbouring countries. Unfortunately Israel has had to maintain military control over the West Bank and Gaza for security reasons because for 75 years Israel has been continuously attacked from those areas. That’s why a peace agreement is essential for peace. For two generations “land for peace” has been the famous equation to solve the conflict. That’s the basis of UNSC 242. If there was no military threat there would be no need for Israel to maintain military control over the West Bank and Gaza. If Palestinian Arabs and other Arabs would finally respect Israel’s right to exist, it’s independence and sovereignty, there would be no conflict.

epaulo13

..that argument doesn't address the massive human rights violation of the occupation, the indiscriminate bombings and the apartheid state. 

..that argument is a get out of jail free card. and something you repeat over and over when faced with a ligitimate arguement. 

..in #66 you asked me 2 questions. in #67 i answered those questions. you need to respond to #67 as a natural conversation flow instead of veering off into the wild blue yonder.   

josh

An organizer in Calgary was arrested and charged with disturbing the peace for chanting, “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” at a protest over the weekend. The police claimed this was an “offensive anti-semitic comment.”

https://x.com/DavideMastracci/status/1721901908913533222?s=20

epaulo13

ALBERTA MUST DROP SPURIOUS CHARGES AGAINST PALESTINE PROTEST ORGANIZER WESAM KHALED!

On Sunday, Nov. 5, following a large and successful protest for Palestinian life and human rights in Calgary, protest organiser Wesam Khaled was arrested by Calgary police.  Charged with "disturbing the peace," the police told Khaled that the charge was related to his use of the chant "From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free,” which the police decided to treat as an “offensive anti-semitic comment.” We reject these attempts by Canadian politicians at all levels of government to demonize such protests and falsely accuse protest organizers as antisemitic, when protesters are simply calling for Palestinians to be able to live in their homeland as free and equal citizens.

Please fill out the form below to send an email to Alberta- and Calgary-based politicians and leaders to insist that they immediately drop all charges against Palestine protest organizer Wesam Khaled!

epaulo13

kropotkin1951
kropotkin1951

From the river to the sea all of Israel will be Palestinian free is the end game and main focus of Zionism.

JKR

One fifth of the citizens of Israel are Palestinians.
 

From the river to the sea the Hamas government wants Palestine to be Jew free.

 

josh

JKR wrote:

One fifth of the citizens of Israel are Palestinians.
 

From the river to the sea the Hamas government wants Palestine to be Jew free.

 

How many of the 3 million or so Palestinians in the occupied west bank and gaza are Israeli citizens? From the river to the sea means one state with equal rights for all. Understandable that you would react in horror to that.

JKR

josh wrote:
JKR wrote:

One fifth of the citizens of Israel are Palestinians.
 

From the river to the sea the Hamas government wants Palestine to be Jew free.

 

How many of the 3 million or so Palestinians in the occupied west bank and gaza are Israeli citizens? From the river to the sea means one state with equal rights for all. Understandable that you would react in horror to that.

Most Palestinians living on the West Bank and Gaza are not Israeli citizens. Officially Palestinian leaders in peace negotiations have told the whole world they support a two-state solution. Are they lying? Plans for a two-state solution have come close to being agreed upon but Palestinian negotiators have always left the negotiating table after supporting a two state solution. Is that why Palestinian leaders always leave the negotiating table and fail to sign a final peace agreement because they don’t really want peace with Israel?

josh

You'll have to ask them.  But we know Israel is lying because they believe in "Jewish control" from the river to the sea, and their illegal settlement policy has made a viable Palestinian state impossible.

JKR

Countries around the world support a two-state solution including China, the U.S., Russia, France, and the UK. Palestinians could have had a state over twenty years ago but unfortunately Arafat walked away from a peace deal. As Abba Eban once famously said - the Palestinian leadership never misses an  opportunity to miss an opportunity.

josh

Countries around the world may accept it, Israel does not.

https://x.com/teh_snowflake/status/1720584958031343812?s=46&t=sbdQQeYBqp0h_Zql717iTw

JKR

josh wrote:

Countries around the world may accept it, Israel does not.

In the early 2000’’s Israel agreed to a two-state solution but Arafat walked away from that peace agreement. Israel also accepted the two-state solution agreed to by the United Nations in 1947/48 but Arab countries opposed it and instead went to war against Israel.

NDPP

Apartheid Israel destroyed any possibility for Palestinians of an equitable or viable 'two state solution' long ago.

JKR

NDPP wrote:

Apartheid Israel destroyed any possibility for Palestinians of an equitable or viable 'two state solution' long ago.

China, Russia, France, the UK, the U.S., the EU, the Arab League, and most other countries in the world support a two-state solution. In any case Israel and Palestinians will have to establish some kind of peace agreement if there is to be peace between Israel and Palestine. Without a peace agreement there is no reason to believe the status quo won’t continue indefinitely.

kropotkin1951

JKR wrote:

Countries around the world support a two-state solution including China, the U.S., Russia, France, and the UK. Palestinians could have had a state over twenty years ago but unfortunately Arafat walked away from a peace deal. As Abba Eban once famously said - the Palestinian leadership never misses an  opportunity to miss an opportunity.

Here is a response to your nonstop Israeli and US propaganda.

Accusations of Israeli and American responsibility

Robert Malley, part of the Clinton administration and present at the summit, wrote to dispel three "myths" regarding the summit's failure. First myth, Malley says, was "Camp David was an ideal test of Mr. Arafat's intentions". Malley recalls that Arafat didn't think that Israeli and Palestinian diplomats had sufficiently narrowed issues in preparation for the summit and that the Summit happened at a "low point" in the relations between Arafat and Barak.[46] The second myth was "Israel's offer met most if not all of the Palestinians' legitimate aspirations". According to Malley, Arafat was told that Israel would not only retain sovereignty over some Arab neighborhoods of Jerusalem, but Haram al Sharif too, and Arafat was also asked to accept an unfavorable 9-to-1 ratio in land swaps.[46] The third myth was that "The Palestinians made no concession of their own". Malley pointed out that the Palestinians starting position was at the 1967 borders, but they were ready to give up Jewish neighborhoods in East Jerusalem, and parts of the West Bank with Israeli settlements. Further, the Palestinians were willing to implement Right of Return in a way that guaranteed Israel's demographic interests. He argues that Arafat was far more compromising in his negotiations with Israel than Anwar el-Sadat or King Hussein of Jordan had been when they negotiated with Israel.[46]

Clayton Swisher wrote a rebuttal to Clinton and Ross's accounts about the causes for the breakdown of the Camp David Summit in his 2004 book, The Truth About Camp David.[47] Swisher, the Director of Programs at the Middle East Institute, concluded that the Israelis and the Americans were at least as guilty as the Palestinians for the collapse. M.J. Rosenberg praised the book: "Clayton Swisher's 'The Truth About Camp David,' based on interviews with [US negotiators] Martin Indyk, Dennis Ross and [Aaron] Miller himself provides a comprehensive and acute account – the best we're likely to see – on the [one-sided diplomacy] Miller describes."[48]

Shlomo Ben-Ami, then Israel's Minister of Foreign Relations who participated in the talks, stated that the Palestinians wanted the immediate withdrawal of the Israelis from the West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem, and only subsequently the Palestinian authority would dismantle the Palestinian organizations. The Israeli response was "we can't accept the demand for a return to the borders of June 1967 as a pre-condition for the negotiation."[49] In 2006, Shlomo Ben-Ami stated on Democracy Now! that "Camp David was not the missed opportunity for the Palestinians, and if I were a Palestinian I would have rejected Camp David, as well. This is something I put in the book. But Taba is the problem. The Clinton parameters are the problem" referring to his 2001 book Scars of War, Wounds of Peace: The Israeli-Arab Tragedy.[50]

Norman Finkelstein published an article in the winter 2007 issue of Journal of Palestine Studies, excerpting from his longer essay called Subordinating Palestinian Rights to Israeli "Needs". The abstract for the article states: "In particular, it examines the assumptions informing Ross’s account of what happened during the negotiations and why, and the distortions that spring from these assumptions. Judged from the perspective of Palestinians' and Israelis' respective rights under international law, all the concessions at Camp David came from the Palestinian side, none from the Israeli side."[51]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_Camp_David_Summit

NDPP

The Demand For A Ceasefire is Necessary But Not Sufficient: The Demand MUST Be For Decolonization and Palestinian Self-Determination

https://blackagendareport.org/news/1663/33/The-Demand-For-a-Ceasefire-is...

No more subordination of Palestinian rights for Apartheid Israel!

JKR

kropotkin1951 wrote:
JKR wrote:

Countries around the world support a two-state solution including China, the U.S., Russia, France, and the UK. Palestinians could have had a state over twenty years ago but unfortunately Arafat walked away from a peace deal. As Abba Eban once famously said - the Palestinian leadership never misses an  opportunity to miss an opportunity.

Here is a response to your nonstop Israeli and US propaganda.

Accusations of Israeli and American responsibility

Robert Malley, part of the Clinton administration and present at the summit, wrote to dispel three "myths" regarding the summit's failure….

I agree that the failure was not caused exclusively by one person or one side. I think Arafat should have accepted the deal. I think Palestinians would be infinitely better off than they are now had Arafat signed a peace agreement. After the deal didn’t pass I think another attempt at a peace deal should have been attempted. Unfortunately the hard liners on both sides are in a synergistic relationship with each other as their uncompromising views just support the uncompromising views of the other side. What’s needed is the moderates from both sides to get together and develop a peace plan which I think would most likely be a two state solution. It would also be very helpful if other nearby countries like Egypt, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia supported a peace plan. I think creative diplomacy could establish a solution that many people have not thought of.

josh

Columbia University suspended a student group Jewish Voice for Peace because of their opposition to Israel.

josh

A 13 yr-old kid in OC, California was called a terrorist by a classmate. He responded w/ "Free Palestine." And was suspended for 3 days.

Per his aunt, "They (school admin) expressed to my nephew that the words 'Free Palestine' meant death to all Jews and should never be said."

https://x.com/atwaheed/status/1723040938992284096?s=20

JKR

josh wrote:
Columbia University suspended a student group Jewish Voice for Peace because of their opposition to Israel.

Luckily Columbia University is opposing anti semitism.

New York Post; Hundreds of Columbia professors sign new letter saying they’re ‘appalled’ and ‘horrified’ about campus antisemitism; By Jesse O’Neill

https://nypost.com/2023/10/31/metro/hundreds-of-columbia-professors-decr...

Hundreds of Columbia professors sign new letter saying they’re ‘appalled’ and ‘horrified’ about campus antisemitism

Jewish students gathered Monday to call on the university to take action against antisemitism on campus.

More than 200 faculty members at Columbia University said Tuesday they were “appalled by the spate of antisemitic incidents” on the Manhattan campus, a day after scores of their colleagues signed a letter defending students who supported Hamas’ brutal Oct. 7 terror attack.

The new letter came after Jewish students rallied on campus to blast the administration’s “inaction” on what they called an “unsafe” atmosphere in the weeks since the attack, due to at least one attack on an Israeli student, death threats and rampant hate speech and vandalism.

While the faculty members agree “there should be robust debate about complex and difficult issues” concerning the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, they say “there is no excuse for Hamas’s barbaric attack on Israeli civilians.”

“We are horrified that anyone would celebrate these monstrous attacks or, as some members of the Columbia faculty have done in a recent letter, try to ‘recontextualize’ them as a ‘salvo,’ as the ‘exercise of a right to resist’ occupation, or as ‘military action,'” the letter reads.

The new missive is signed by many highly distinguished professors and notable academics from around the world.

They includine honorary Knight Commander of the British Empire Philip Bobbitt, who is professor of Federal Jurisprudence at Columbia; noted physicist Tanya Zelevinsky, who is winner of the prestigious Brown Investigator Award; and assistant professor of electrical engineering and computer science Asaf Cidon, who is winner of the National Science Foundation career award.

The statement continued: “Finally, the University cannot tolerate violence, speech that incites it, or hate speech. Just as we condemn any bigoted comments or acts directed at Palestinian and Muslim students, we are appalled by the spate of antisemitic incidents on campus since October 7,” citing “epithets, physical assault, and swastikas.”

“In the same way that the University defends other groups from this sort of disgusting conduct, it is essential to do the same for Jewish and Israeli students,” the letter said.

In a statement to The Post Monday, a university spokesperson said “antisemitism or any other form of hate … will not be tolerated”

“We are using every available tool to keep our community safe and that includes protecting our Jewish students from antisemitic discrimination or harassment.”

Advertisement

However, the university has not elaborated on which “tools” they are using and what action they are taking beyond the letter-writing campaigns. Officials chose not to elaborate Tuesday when pressed for additional comment on how they planned to counter the “hostile and unsafe environment” on campus.

English major Ken Vasques, 21 said Monday the university has been on edge since Israel waged war on Gaza following the coordinated terror attack that killed more than 1,400 residents of the Jewish state.

“It’s been a weird time to be on campus. There has been a feeling of dread. There’s a feeling something will break out,” he said.

“The vans parked outside of school have been doxxing people. Students have been covering the vans every day. The school hasn’t done anything. You would think the school would put the students’ safety first,” Vasques continued.

Advertisement

“Professors have been hesitant to address the war or students’ response to it. One of my professors moved the whole class to Zoom because the atmosphere around campus has been so tense.

“As a student I feel I have to be mindful of what I say and I think professors have felt that as well.”

josh

JVP are Jews, Murdoch Post fan.

JKR

josh wrote:

JVP are Jews, Murdoch Post fan.

Is there anything in that article that’s not true?

JKR

From JVP's membership page: 

https://www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org/join-us/

Do I have to be Jewish to join JVP?

No, you don’t.

JVP is an organization that is inspired by Jewish values and traditions to work towards peace and justice.

We are committed to building an inclusive Jewish community, that, like many of our families, welcomes Jews and allies who share our values and appreciate our traditions, who advocate for an end to Israeli human rights abuses, and who oppose anti-Jewish hatred, anti-Arab racism, and Islamophobia.

JKR

Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP): What You Need to Know

https://www.adl.org/resources/blog/jewish-voice-peace-jvp-what-you-need-know

  • Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP) is a radical anti-Israel and anti-Zionist activist group that advocates for the boycott of Israel and eradication of Zionism.
  • JVP does not represent the mainstream Jewish community, which it views as bigoted for its association with Israel. JVP’s staunch anti-Zionist positions place it squarely in opposition to mainstream American Jews and Jews worldwide, most of whom view a connection with Israel as an integral part of their social, cultural or religious Jewish identities. JVP promulgates the view that Jews who identify even tangentially with Israel are motivated by white supremacy, Jewish racial chauvinism and religious supremacism.
  • The spread of JVP’s most inflammatory ideas can help give rise to antisemitism. Many left-wing groups have uncritically accepted JVP’s anti-Zionist claims, elevating their harsh rhetoric related to Israel and Zionism and furthering the widespread antisemitic vilification and ostracization of many American Jews who identify as Zionists. This has helped to create a hostile environment for Jews on many campuses and in many progressive spaces.
  • JVP alleges that law enforcement missions to Israel organized by Jewish groups help to perpetuate police brutality. Since 2017, JVP has claimed that Israel, alongside a few U.S.-based community and Jewish organizations, is responsible for “police brutality, especially against people of color, on American streets” because those organizations have facilitated periodic seminars between American and Israeli law enforcement officials. This “Deadly Exchange” narrative has metastasized within American progressive circles, with some implicating Zionism and Israel in the murder of George Floyd and the broader oppression of people of color in the United States. JVP’s willful misrepresentation of policeexchanges injects extreme anti-Israel animus into important social justice movements, detracting from pressing civil rights work and often leading to the vilification of American Jews.
  • Approximately 12 JVP chapters are active on college campuses, where members often work closely with chapters of the anti-Israel student group Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) to promote anti-Israel initiatives, messages and events.
  • In addition to JVP’s promotion of messaging that descends into the antisemitic vilification of “Zionists,” the group has expressed support for violence and, occasionally, classic antisemitic tropes. Some JVP members, leaders and chapters propagate rhetoric or sponsor events where participants express support for violence or terror against Israelis and vilify Zionist Jews. In a few instances, they have espoused blatant antisemitic tropes, including modern manifestations of the blood libel and allegations of Jewish dual loyalty to the countries in which they live.

Statements and Images That Invoke Classic Antisemitic Tropes

Occasionally, JVP activists or speakers at JVP events veer into classic antisemitic ideas and themes. In at least two instances, JVP or participants at a JVP-organized event propagated allegations related to the blood libel. In another instance, a JVP leader argued that genocidal sentiment towards non-Jews is embedded in Judaism, a claim that has also been made by hardcore antisemites

josh

The Anti-Defamation of Israel League.?  LOL.

https://www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org/

https://www.ifnotnowmovement.org/

Two wonderful Jewish organizations fighting the Zionist thugs who are intent on killing as many Palestinians as possible and taking and occupying their land. 

 

 

Paladin1

Montreal lecturer suspended in fallout of Concordia altercation over Israel-Hamas war

A professor telling a woman to go back to Poland and calling them a whore seems perfectly rational.

 

epaulo13

..from the peacemaker thread.

What US media is missing in Israel’s war on Gaza...and why it matters | The Listening Post

Freedom of expression is under the gun in the Land of the Free.

 

epaulo13

..according to the above video..4.57 mark..2/3rds of americans want a cease fire. 

and growing.

Paladin1
Mobo2000

A summary of some news articles on suppression of pro-Palestinian protestors.   

https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/ah-freedom

".... the systematic silencing of Palestinian and Palestine-supporting voices is happening, no one is even pretending that it’s not happening, and it’s a direct threat to the basic principles of free expression that are supposed to apply to everyone and every topic, no matter what. A bunch of the people who have dined out on free speech for years are saying nothing because Zionism is more dear to them than civil liberties, and now it’s time for all of us to state our basic allegiances when it comes to free expression. I include that snippet from an interview with an Israeli settler because it’s an unusually frank statement of what many people support without explicitly saying so: that Palestinians must live under Israeli rule without basic democratic rights, in perpetuity. You either think everyone who lives under the power of a government should have democratic representation in that government, or you don’t. A principle is a thing you believe all the time. For fifteen years I’ve defended the free speech rights of people I deplore. Some supposed defenders of free expression cracked in a day. You believe in it all the time, or you don’t believe in it at all. It’s up to you."

 

epaulo13

Capitol Police Violently Break Up Jewish-Organized DNC Protest Calling for Gaza Ceasefire

AMY GOODMAN: President Biden is facing increasing pressure to call for a ceasefire in Gaza. But instead, the White House is rushing more arms to Israel. Bloomberg is reporting the U.S. has quietly sent Israel more laser-guided missiles for Apache gunships, as well as new army vehicles, bunker-buster munitions and more ammunition. On Wednesday, the United States abstained from a United Nations Security Council vote in support of extended humanitarian pauses in Gaza.

quote:

AMY GOODMAN: Protest organizers say 90 people were injured outside the DNC. Capitol police say six of their officers sustained injuries. One person was arrested.

One lawmaker who was inside the DNC, California Congressmember Brad Sherman, took to social media to describe the demonstrators as, quote, “pro-terrorist, anti-Israel protestors.” On Thursday, President Biden called into a DNC meeting to express his appreciation for how law enforcement handled the protest.

We’re joined right now by that person you just heard, Eva Borgwardt, national spokesperson for IfNotNow.

Thanks so much for joining us from D.C., Eva. If you can start off by calling — by explaining why you focused on the DNC? And then describe what happened and respond to Congressmember Sherman saying you are pro-terrorist.

EVA BORGWARDT: Well, Amy, thank you so much for having me.

And, yes, the focus on the DNC was because, as we know, the majority of Americans, and certainly the majority of Democrats, want a ceasefire. And our lawmakers are not listening to the thousands of calls and constituent meetings that we’ve been trying — ways that we’ve been trying to reach them over the past month. And so, this was, like many protests across the country, an act of nonviolent civil disobedience. The goal was to assemble peacefully, call attention to the urgent situation in Gaza and ask for Democratic leadership to act and call for a ceasefire now, a release of the hostages, a hostage exchange and a deescalation and to address the root causes of this violence — decades of occupation, apartheid and siege.

And unfortunately, police chose to escalate. And with no verbal warnings or communication with police liaisons who were trying to speak with them, they started shoving protesters down the stairs and shoving protesters back with their bicycles and trampling on the 11,000 tea lights that protesters had brought to represent the Palestinians who have already been killed in Gaza.

And as you mentioned, Democratic lawmakers, including Congressman Brad Sherman, have said that these protesters are pro-Hamas. Speaker Mike Johnson said that this was an antisemitic protest, which is, frankly, absurd, because — for many reasons, but primarily so many of the protesters are not only Jews, but who have loved ones who were either murdered by Hamas on October 7th or Jews and Palestinians who have loved ones either in Gaza or who know people in Gaza who have lost dozens of members of their families over the past month. And so, to say that these, again, many of them personally grieving protesters are pro-terrorist is absurd. And let’s be clear that police escalated this protest.

quote:

 

EVA BORGWARDT: Yes, well, and I was also at that protest at Senator Sanders’ office earlier this month. And I think, in particular, for Jewish lawmakers, as a Jewish movement, as the Jewish movements that have been protesting for ceasefire, we are doing this for safety and freedom for Palestinians who are under siege, and also because we are terrified for our loved ones in Israel and in the entire region if this escalates into a broader regional war. And our disappointment in Senator Sanders so far refraining from calling for a ceasefire is that he has made his legacy as an antiwar champion. And so, we are extremely grateful to Congresswoman Balint for speaking out from a Jewish perspective for ceasefire, because we feel that our Jewish values and our safety as Jews is extremely, extremely contingent on ending this horrific violence and calling for a ceasefire now.

AMY GOODMAN: And finally, Eva, you were an organizer for President Biden during his 2020 campaign. If you can talk about your response to his position now, and what this means, and what you feel Biden supporters then are feeling today?

EVA BORGWARDT: Yes. So, like you mentioned, I worked for President Biden in Arizona in the 2020 election. Let’s be clear: I am terrified of Donald Trump and the white supremacist, antisemitic movement that’s behind him. And I feel immense stake in the Democratic Party winning in November 2024. And frankly, again, I am deeply terrified and angry at Democratic leadership for ignoring the calls from the majority of their base for a ceasefire, a hostage exchange and a deescalation, and creating a lack of faith in the Democratic Party that I am very concerned will hurt Democrats’ chances in November.

And I encourage them, with the fullest, fullest emphasis possible, to reverse course now. We have seen so far that for some Democrats, 1,400 Israeli deaths and over 4,000 Palestinian deaths were enough. Now, for other Democrats, 11,000 Palestinians in Gaza killed are not enough for them to call for ceasefire, which is how we know this horrific violence will end and move toward a political solution in the region. And so, we are waiting to see how many Palestinian lives our Democratic politicians need in order to call for ceasefire. And every day, every hour that they wait has, I fear, implications for what will happen in November.....

josh

A day after Elon Musk agreed with blatant anti-Semitism on Twitter, the head of the U.S. Anti-Defamation League, praised Musk for banning the slogan "from the river to the sea" on Twitter without saying a word about Musk's anti-Semitism.  The head of a group supposedly dedicated to fighting anti-Semitism praising an anti-Semite because they are anti-Palestinian 

 

https://x.com/emilyctamkin/status/1725701411860599194?s=20

Pages