Ireland Turns Left in Election

55 posts / 0 new
Last post
jerrym

The Irish are well aware from their own history of the Irish Famine that famine is a political act. In fact, there many famines throughout English control of Ireland as all other crops went to the English landlords and to feed England and the British army in India. The 1845-1853 Irish Famine was by far the worst. A century before the 1845-1853 Irish Famine Jonathan Swift wrote "A Modest Proposal", in which he satirized English economists by proposing that Irish peasants, who led lives of destitution and often faced starvation, could profit by offering up their children to be fattened up and then fed to wealthy Englishmen in return for some money to feed the rest of their family. That is why they could quickly see what was happening in Gaza was another political act of famine and become the first Western nation to oppose the war and the famine. By December January every member of the Irish Parliament, whether on the right, centre or left, voted for a permanent ceasefire and an end to the famine. Having seen how famine was used repeatedly as a political act of violence in their own country, the Irish have spoken out most strongly in the West against the Israeli war in Gaza and the resulting famine. 

In Irish Australian writer Thomas Keneally's book, Three Famines, Keneally compares the 1845-1853 famine, with the World War II famine in Bengal India, and the 1980s famine in Ethopia and ends up agreeing with Irish economic historian Cormac O'Grada that "Agency is more important than a food production shortfall. Mars (the god of war) is more important than Malthus (who argued that population growth would eventually produce famine). Thus famines are acts of political violence. In 1837, Ireland freed its slaves, spending 20% of its budget to do so. Of course this money went to the slaveowneers to compensate them for their loss of property; needless to say, not one cent went to the slaves for the abuse they endured or the lost labour wages. Ten years later, the English claimed they could not afford to feed the starving Irish, something that would have cost significantly less than 20% of the budget. The government's own documents show that Ireland produced enough food to feed everyone in Ireland, but the English took that under armed guard to feed England and its army in India. One quarter of the Irish starved to death and another quarter were forced to emigrate to survive, which seems to be Israel's desired goal as the famine in Gaza mounts. 

Similarly, Keneally describes how famine in Ethiopia was also the result of ideological conflict, much more than food shortfall. The fact that any response to feeding starving Ethiopians took so long to occur, was in part a response of the West to a 'African problem'. Kenally in a last chapter goes on goes on discuss numerous other famines, including those in the Russian famines in 1921-22 during the civil war, Ukraine in the 1930s, Malawi in 1949-50, Cambodia in the 1970s, North Korea in the 1990s, illustrating in each case how these were political acts of violence. The famine in Gaza that is now occurring is also a political act of violence. 

During World War II, although England had the means to ship enough to feed to feed Bengalis in India, Churchill decided it was more important to focus on the war effort, leaving millions to starve to death in India. Since this inconvenient truth did not show England in a good light, this is one of the few large famines that is barely known outside of India. Copying the Irish Republican Army (IRA) that fought for and won Irish independence a couple of generations after the famine, the Indian Republican Army also fought for independence in part because of the Indian famine in WWII. While the Indian Republican Army failed and its leaders were executed as allies of Japan in WWII, it still had an effect on Indian history. The Imperial Indian army, mostly composed of Indians under English control, was ready to go into open rebellion in 1947, forcing England to give India independence one year earlier than had been planned. (https://www.indianetzone.com/60/indian_republican_army.htm) "Independence leaders such as Jawaharlal Nehru and Irish Prime Minister Éamon de Valera were said to be in touch with each other" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/India–Ireland_relations), despite Nehru being an advocate of non-violence and a leading disciple of Ghandi.

jerrym

The leader of the largest Unionist party, MP Sir Jeffrey Donaldson, in Northern Ireland has just been charged with "rape and multiple other sexual offences", causing him to be suspended from the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP). "This is a political bombshell like no other in Northern Ireland. Sir Jeffrey Donaldson was at the peak of his powers. He steered his party back into Stormont in the face of opposition of many of his own MPs and peers. But now his political career appears to be over and his party has been left in disarray. "

The Democratic Unionist Party was founded in 1971 by Protestant clergyman Ia Paisley who argued that the Pope was the Anti-Christ and that he was in alliance with the Communists to rule the world with their first target being Northern Ireland. Although Paisley campaigned against the Good Friday Agreement that brought peace to Ireland in 1997, he accepted the role of First Minister in the Northern Ireland Parliament with a Sinn Fein (Republican, mainly Catholic) deputy First Minister as laid out in the Good Friday Agreement, after his DUP became the largest party in Northern Ireland in 2007. But in the 2022 election Sinn Fein became the largest political party in Northern Ireland, making it the party who chose the First Minister. For two years the DUP refused to participate in a Sinn Fein government, thereby ending government by Northern Ireland and shifting it to the control of the English Parliament. In January 2024, as even Protestants became increasingly frustrated with the lack of a Northern Ireland government, Donaldson over the objections of some of his own members, agreed to return the DUP to the Northern Ireland Parliament in a new government in February. What happens now is uncertain. The following url covers the history of the DUP: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_Unionist_Party

Sir Jeffrey Donaldson MP has been charged with rape and other historical sexual offences and has resigned as Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) leader. A 57-year-old woman has also been charged with aiding and abetting in connection with the alleged offences. They were both arrested on Thursday morning by PSNI detectives and were questioned before being charged on Thursday night.

Sir Jeffrey had said that he will be strenuously contesting the charges. He and the 57-year-old woman are due to appear in court next month. ...

Police issued a statement on Friday morning, but did not disclose the identity of those charged.  The statement said a 61-year-old man had been charged with "non-recent sexual offences" adding that a 57-year-old woman was also arrested at the same time and charged with "aiding and abetting additional offences". The statement also confirmed the pair would appear before Newry Magistrates' Court on 24 April.

This is a political bombshell like no other in Northern Ireland. Sir Jeffrey Donaldson was at the peak of his powers. He steered his party back into Stormont in the face of opposition of many of his own MPs and peers. But now his political career appears to be over and his party has been left in disarray. Gavin Robinson has now stepped up and will attempt to steady the party which has been rocked by the allegations facing its former leader.

Mindful of the potential risks to Stormont, Sinn Féin First Minister Michelle O'Neill warned that the Executive must continue to deliver for the whole community. A coded warning to the DUP to look beyond its own internal challenges and keep the bigger political prize in view....

Sir Jeffrey Donaldson was elected leader of the DUP in 2021. He is also the longest serving MP in Northern Ireland having been first elected to Parliament in 1997. ... 

Sir Jeffrey recently steered his party back in to government in Northern Ireland ending a two year boycott of the Stormont institutions. The DUP had walked out of government in protest at the Northern Ireland Protocol, claiming the post-Brexit arrangements had undermined their place in the UK. Sir Jeffrey was first elected to parliament in 1997 as a representative of the Ulster Unionist Party (UUP). In 2003, following long-standing opposition to the Good Friday Agreement and the leadership of David Trimble, he announced he would leave the UUP, later joining the DUP. He was awarded a knighthood in 2016 for political service.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ireland-68686691

NDPP

'The Most Pro-Palestine Country in Euope'

https://twitter.com/PMacoscair/status/1775088913717100928

"A reminder that despite being 'the most pro-Palestine country in Europe', Ireland is still Israel's 4th biggest trading partner and has yet to pass any diplomatic, sporting or cultural boycott despite the events of the last 6 months."

jerrym

Ireland's position position on the Gaza war doesn't sound much different from China's position, the country with the largest trade surplus with Israel. Like Ireland, since 1992, "China and Israel have developed increasingly close economic, military and technological links with each other. China is Israel's third largest trading partner globally and largest trading partner in East Asia.... Though relations are close and generally good with no particular bilateral problems between the two nations, China and Israel continue to remain divided on the issue of Palestine, Israeli settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, economic blockade of Gaza, and the Israeli West Bank barrier wall." (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China–Israel_relations#:~:text=Since%201992%2C%20China%20and%20Israel,trading%20partner%20in%20East%20Asia.)

Israel incurred the highest trade deficits with the following countries.

  1. mainland China: -US$14.8 billion (country-specific trade deficit in 2022)
  2. Türkiye: -$4.4 billion
  3. Germany: -$4.3 billion
  4. Italy: -$2.1 billion
  5. Russia: -$1.8 billion
  6. South Korea: -$1.2 billion

 

The Irish Ministry of Foreign Affairs notes that " Ireland has a longstanding commitment to a just and sustainable peace in the Middle East based on a two-State solution."(https://www.dfa.ie/our-role-policies/international-priorities/middle-eas...) The Minister of Foreign Affairs for the Republic of Ireland, Michael Martin, as a representative of the only Western government supporting the Palestinians, made this comment in the Irish Parliament about Gaza, the war and the resulting famine, noting the support of all members, of all political parties of the right, centre and left, of the Irish Parliament for his statement: 

Quote: 

"All of us in this House are united in our view that what is happening in Gaza must stop. There should and must be a ceasefire. All of us here – and all of the Irish people – are appalled by what we see unfolding. 1.9 million people have been displaced from their homes and have nowhere safe to go. At least 10,000 of the 26,000 Palestinians that have been killed in Gaza since October are children. 90% of the 2.3 million people in Gaza are now acutely food insecure and that the UN is warning of a real risk of famine. No one in this House believes that any of this is acceptable." 

 

(https://www.gov.ie/en/speech/af84b-tanaiste-dail-statement-on-south-afri...)

 

The position paper on Resolving the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict of the Chinese government says

The current Palestinian-Israeli conflict has caused heavy civilian casualties and a serious humanitarian disaster. It is a grave concern of the international community. President Xi Jinping stated China’s principled position on the current Palestinian-Israeli situation on a number of occasions. He stressed the need for an immediate ceasefire and ending the fighting, ensuring that the humanitarian corridors are safe and unimpeded, and preventing the expansion of the conflict.

https://www.mfa.gov.cn/eng/wjbxw/202311/t20231129_11189405.html#:~:text=...'s,the%20expansion%20of%20the%20conflict.

Pages